Vote No

Neo-Liberalism

War
Democracy
Resources
Get Involved
Homepage
Lisbon Treaty Frequently Asked Questions Answered

Campaign Against the EU Constitution

We Dont have big business backers, We need your help if we are to win. please Donate to the Vote No Campaign

To get involved text VoteNo to
087 6347648

Volunteer to campaign e mail: info@voteno.ie

Who we are:

VoteNo.ie is a website that is initiated by socialists to campaign for a No vote.
We will include material from a wide variety of sources – some of which differ from our own stances - as long as they are not promoting racist or right-wing nationalist views.

This site has two editors:

Kieran Allen is the author of the Booklet Reasons to VOTE NO to the Lisbon Treaty and a number of other books, including The Corporate Take Over of Ireland (2007) and The Celtic Tiger: The Myth of Social Partnership (2000)

Sinead Kennedy has written on culture and politics, women and the Celtic Tiger.
She is a long standing campaigner against war and for women’s rights.

Both Kieran & Sinead are also members of the Socialist Workers Party

You can contact the editors on:
info@VoteNo.ie

VoteNo.ie Emergency Apeal for funds. Help us win Please Donate here

Latest 30.09.2009
How The EU Parliament Really Works

Supporters of the Yes camp claim that the Lisbon Treaty will bring more democracy because it gives new powers to the EU Parliament.

But they rarely explain how this parliament really works.

Unlike virtually any other legislative assembly in the world, the parliamentarians are not allowed to initiate legislation. They cannot, for example, introduce a Private Members Bill which could, be voted into law. Only the unelected EU Commission is allowed to draw up legislation which can be voted on.

Once they do so, a bizarre procedure is put in place. Here Tony Bunyan, of State watch explains how the procedure works. This appeared in the Guardian newspaper in Britain on 3 September 2009. Read More

Secrets and laws

MEPs should remember that their primary loyalty is to the people who elected them - they must cast aside the EU's secret legislative process

As the European parliament (EP) begins its new term major questions hang over the lack of transparency and accountability of its legislative process. In the previous five-year term (2004-2009) over 80% of new measures were agreed behind closed doors in secret "trilogue" sessions, meetings between the Council of the European Union (the 27 governments), the EP and the European Commission.

Codecision is the EU legislative process which requires the EP and the council to agree on the final text. In the parliament there are four stages to the procedure.

Trilogues were originally intended to cover uncontroversial and complex technical measures but they are now used to negotiate the vast majority of new measures going through the EU. Meetings take place before the parliament adopts its formal first reading opinion and the council adopts its "common position".

During these negotiations the parliament is represented by its rapporteur and the shadow rapporteurs (from other political groups). Documents discussed in the trilogue meetings are not published and after agreement is reached the parliament's committees and full plenary sessions cannot change as much as a dot or comma. Surely we must acknowledge that open parliamentary sessions cannot have a meaningful debate if the "deal" has already been agreed.

In the last five-year term 69.5% of the parliament's business were concluded at first reading. 11.8% were approved without amendment by early second reading agreements (also settled in secret trilogues), just 12.8% went through the classical second reading votes. This process of course suits the council (the EU governments). It likes cosy meetings where governments can negotiate and seal a secret deal that cannot be overturned by open debate in the parliament.

The council's view on access to first and second reading documents was summed up by Hubert Legal, of the council legal service, when he appeared before the House of Lords select committee on the EU in June.

During ongoing legislative procedures there is not a general right for the public to access documents if the fact of giving access would undermine the institutional decision-making process.

Legal goes on to say that when "the procedure is completed" (ie: the measure is agreed) public access is given. Thus the public and civil society have no right to know what is being discussed before it is adopted. Just think of the uproar if a national parliament behaved in this fashion. Imagine a government publishing a bill, then negotiating in secret with other parties, before presenting the full parliament with as a fait accompli.

The council of the European Union, with the tacit support of the European parliament, seems intent on trying to justify a process of decision-making reminiscent of colonial times. Do they truly consider it dangerous for the people to know what is being decided in their name?

First reading trilogue "deals" are held in secret, no records (minutes) are released. The process removes meaningful debate, disagreements, options, votes in committee meetings and the plenary sessions - both of which are open and the documents discussed are publicly accessible. The practice pre-empts a wider debate in parliament, the media and society at large. Respect for the European Parliament has never been more fragile, the June elections saw the voter turnout drop to its lowest ever number, just 43% voted.

It is a problem that is set to deepen even further unless the European parliament casts aside "inter-institutional loyalty" to the council and remembers that its primary loyalty is to the people who elected it.

Booklet cover: Reasons to Vote No to the Lisbon Treaty
  • Booklet: 'Reasons to Vote No to the Lisbon Treaty' - Kieran Allen
    to order Send €3 to P.O. Box 1648
    Dublin 8 or bulk orders
    €25 for ten copies.
  • If you want to volunteer to help promote left wing material against the Treaty, you can sign up to receive our newsletter or volunteer to become an activist. [HERE]
  • Contact information: www.VoteNo.ie E mail: info@voteno.ie To get involved text VoteNo to 087 6347648